17.2 pts
to Lucid Trading
The full 11-factor scorecard.
Each factor scored 0-10 then weighted into the composite. Bars are color-saturated for the winner of each row, dimmed for the runner-up. Weights from the published methodology.
Who wins which category.
Bucket scores are factor-weighted averages within each methodology bucket. Auto-generated from the raw data above — regenerated on every refresh.
Safety 7.1vs9.1
On Safety (Trust, Payouts, Regulatory), Lucid Trading wins clearly. Years operating, identified leadership, Trustpilot footprint, and verified payout volume add up in Lucid Trading's favor. If counterparty risk is your top concern, the safer pick is Lucid Trading.
Terms 8.1vs9.0
On Terms (Profit Split, Challenge Difficulty, Rule Flexibility, Value for Price), Lucid Trading wins slightly. Lower entry fee per $1k of funding, looser challenge structure, or better trader permissions tilt this bucket. The trader-facing economics favor Lucid Trading.
Execution & Growth 7.6vs9.2
On Execution & Growth (Trading Conditions, Scaling Potential, Customer Support), Lucid Trading wins clearly. Platform variety, scaling cap, and support responsiveness combined. If you're planning to scale beyond the initial account size, Lucid Trading gives you more headroom.
Social Proof 5.0vs8.9
On Social Proof (Community Sentiment), Lucid Trading wins clearly. Independent reviewer consensus across Reddit, Discord, and YouTube, combined with Trustpilot trajectory. Lucid Trading has the more positive community signal right now.
Top-3 accounts from each firm.
Each account scored individually with our account-level methodology (re-weights factors 4, 5, 6, 7, 9 using account-specific data). Compare apples-to-apples by size and program type.
Blue Guardian TOP-3
Lucid Trading TOP-3
Pick a firm and start the challenge.
Both affiliate links carry our tracking code. Discount codes are firm-published, not exclusives — copy and paste at checkout.
Compare these firms with peers.
Each link is a separate full scorecard. Browse to triangulate the right firm for your trading style.